Showing posts with label Notes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Notes. Show all posts

All the Hard Work!


 All these crossed lines, repeated measurements, and corrected notes! This is a true learning here.  No "ready-made" answers, all of what students learn, they discover themselves.  I prefer the workbook in which I see the process of discovery rather than a nice note copied from somewhere.  Nowadays, you can easily find an answer to any question, just by opening your favorite browser... That, however, is not learning.  That is copying answers from the Internet.  Sometimes I am under the impression that copying without understanding.  
I propose something different: a hard-copy workbook in which you must write yourself, correct, re-do... Yes, I like the workbook which shows the process, not the final product.  

Accurate results in measuring the wavelength of red light (diffraction method)


The picture above shows the measurement method based on the diffraction formula 
nl = d sin q
Students measure x (distance between the central and the first maximum) and L (distance between the diffraction grating and the screen).  Despite very simple methods, the results are accurate.  The table below presents the results.  Percent error is calculated between the experimental value and the 680 nm red diode laser.
Table by Nicole, Marya, and Rudemy.

All the hard work!

The paper presented above (posted here with the author's permission) documents all the hard work that students put into measuring indicated quantities.  To me, that paper has a lot more value than a nice copy of the results. It shows all the struggles, trials, errors, and victories on the way to understand the nature of sound phenomena.  
The challenge associated with this approach to learning is that the students must go through some confusion at first to finally come to better clarification.  If accepted, that challenge leads to knowledge based on experience - way above the knowledge from a textbook or a lecture.